Categories
Editorials News Writing Tips

How to write compelling concert reviews

Reviews are a dime a dozen these days, but a great live review by an engaging author can still make the difference between a tour’s success or failure.

Ah, the concert review. It has been a staple of entertainment journalism longer than almost any other feature, appearing long before recorded music was even thought possible, and it will most likely outlast us all. Why? For starters, the financial risk in seeing virtually any show is much higher than consuming a single song, album, or movie. Most people will risk $10 on a new release, but far fewer people are willing to spend $30 (or in many cases, much more) to see a performance whose quality is uncertain.

Then there’s the YouTube problem. Just last week, I saw Kelly Clarkson tell a crowd of thousands at Van Andel Arena how much she appreciated their attendance by admitting, “I don’t know if I like anyone enough to leave my house. You could have watched this whole thing on YouTube from your couch, but you’re here, and that means something.”

There are thousands of hours of concert videos on YouTube. In the time it takes to read this article there will likely be hundreds, if not thousands more than when you started. A lot of the clips feature muddy sound and poor video quality, but there remains more than enough decent uploads to sustain those unwilling or unable to purchase tickets for themselves. Just look at this video from the latest Panic! At The Disco tour, which is currently making its way across North America:

The clip above may not duplicate the live experience, but for many, it’s good enough.

These reasons, as well as many others, explain why creating quality live reviews is so important in entertainment today. A compelling live review can determine whether or not a ticket is bought, which plays a role in whether or not artists can support themselves and continue to create.

The importance of criticism in regards to concerts is as much about the performers on stage as it is the production, the crowd, and the overall vibe of the event. Journalists can speak to all these elements on a technical level, but what really grabs today’s easily distracted reader is the critic’s own journey. The consumer of your material may never make it to the show in question themselves, and the reasons for that are numerous (schedule, cost, etc.). What they can do, however, is live vicariously through you.

In today’s entertainment writing culture, the key to crafting a great live review lies in learning how to tell a good story — your story. You should consider yourself, your feelings, and everything that goes into a night out on assignment as a vessel for others. Capture as many moments as possible, especially the tiny moments that others in the crowd might miss, and use them to make your story more engaging for the reader. Here are some questions to get you started:

  • What is the weather like?
  • Is it hot or cold inside the venue?
  • Do people look happy to be there?
  • When did the venue staff notice people lining up? (Don’t be afraid to ask!)
  • What are people in the crowd talking about?
  • What are people in the crowd wearing?
  • How much time between sets?
  • Did the performers engage the audience? If so, how?
  • What moments from this show will you remember in six months?
  • What would you change, if anything, to improve the night?
  • How did you feel during the show?
  • Were your expectations met?
  • Where were your expectations?

2019 is shaping up to be a banner year for live entertainment. Legendary acts are returning to the stage for a final run, new artists are trying to fill large venues, and there appear to be more festivals than ever before. Everyone who is anyone is trying to get a piece of consumers’ live entertainment budget. The reality is, only a few will succeed, and critics can play an active role in determining who comes out on top.

Categories
News

The night Julien Baker changed my life

The following editorial was written in response to an experience our own Marketing Manager, James Shotwell, had while attending SXSW in Austin, TX last week.

You wouldn’t be wrong to assume there is a significant lack of new music discovery taking place at South By Southwest. Having attended the world’s largest annual music conference nearly ten years in a row I have witnessed a slow, but steady growth in the number of already established acts taking center stage in Austin during the one week everyone is supposedly setting aside to find out what is next for our industry. From Deftones and Drake, to Future, Erykah Badu, and even country icon Loretta Lynn, SXSW 2016 might have been the most star-studded installment of the now thirty-year old event to ever be held. Still, for those willing to skip the headliners performing more or less for free on every block, there is a lot of great music waiting to be heard, and late last week I stumbled across an artist who almost immediately turned my world upside down.

The Parish is a small, but beautiful venue nestled above a pizza place on Austin’s world renowned Sixth Street strip that boasts a capacity of just 450. When I arrived at the base of the venue on Thursday night the sun had just begun to set and the St. Patrick’s Day crowd on the streets was becoming increasingly inebriated. A pair of friends in music PR had told me to catch a set from Julien Baker, a young female singer-songwriter signed to 6131 Records, because they had seen her performing in a church the night before and had claimed to be moved to tears by her voice. I was skeptical, not to mention as sober as the day I was born, but I figured there must be something to this largely unknown talent if she could have made such an emotional impact on people who spend their lives seeking out new talent.

In the minutes before Julien took the stage I surveyed the room and found a healthy mix of young and old people from all walks of life staring intently at their phones from various corners of the venue. The crowd near the stage was sparse, or at least it was until the lights began to fade, but the energy amongst them was palpable. These were people who had waited hours, if not days, for a chance to see Julien perform. I, however, had no idea what the fuss was all about. Singer-songwriters are a dime a dozen after all, so how could one woman with no accompaniment other than her electric Fender six-string and a looping pedal demand such reverence in a place where everyone had spent at least one or two days being fueled by free drinks and cheap tacos?

Julien’s arrival on stage was met with the kind of applause that can only come from people who are expecting the person on stage to move them on an emotional level. The excitement was clear, though just a bit restrained, as if those cheering were simultaneously shuffling the items around in the backpack, fanny pack, or purse to find that one small package of travel tissues their mother or significant other had suggested they take on this trip. I didn’t have such items on me, and as I observed several people pulling the sleeves of their hooded sweatshirts over their hands I realized others were facing the same dilemma as myself. We had all come to see this artist who was unquestionably gaining buzz, but none of us were entirely sure what to expect from her performance.

If I told you I knew the songs Julien opened with I would be lying, but by the time the second song in her set was complete I felt a familiar shiver run down my spine. In the span of what couldn’t have been more than five or six minutes the crowd near the staged had swelled to the point that the venue felt packed. No one was pushing and no one was shoving, but something was clearly making a very meaningful impact. I swiveled my head from left to right as the third song began and my jaw slowly became unhinged as I witnessed men and women, from teens to grey-haired adults, trying their hardest to not bring attention to the fact their faces were soaked with tears. Every now and then I would catch someone wipe their eyes with my peripheral vision, but most let their emotions flow. They didn’t sing, they didn’t dance, and they definitely didn’t try to engage with Baker from the crowd. They, and by they I mean more than ¾ of the audience I could see, seemingly wanted nothing more than to live in the moment. It didn’t matter what song was being played or what was happening outside the Parish walls because for a short amount of time they and I were able to co-exist in a moment made special by one woman, a guitar, and a voice that must be heard to be believed.

By the time Julien reached “Everybody Does,” a song that details the feeling of believing no one will want you if they know the real you, something in me began to shift. The best way I can describe the rush of what felt like fresh blood through my veins is to say it was like the first time you realized music was more than something that played in the background while the rest of life was taking place. It was slow and gradual at first, starting at the tips of my fingers and moving up my arms like the worst case of goosebumps you have ever known, and as the sensation reached my heart I could feel my chest swell with a sense of knowing that something had struck a chord deep within my soul. The melody coming from Julien’s soft-spoken voice had touched on something even I didn’t know I was avoiding, and within a matter of moments the recognition of that fact became too much for my small frame to contain. Like those around me, I too began to cry, but not necessarily because I was sad. I cried because, for once, I felt as if someone got me in a way few people ever could, and it was clear from the lack of dry eyes in the room that others felt the same.

That old adage about how when music hits you feel no pain is a lie. The best music is the stuff that crawls under your skin and into your bloodstream, submerging itself within your DNA strands, and through doing so exposes secrets you’ve kept locked away from everyone, including yourself. As Julien Baker strummed ever-so-softly on her faded yellow guitar I could feel her music seeping into my pores. Her angelic voice bounced off the walls of the crowded venue where everyone had gathered to see her perform and she took it all in with a level of grace and humbleness rarely found in alternative music today. I don’t know if she could see everyone who had come to see her perform, but she could certainly see far enough to grasp the impact she was having on the audience. As her voice rose to hit the highest notes her eyes gazed upwards as if to beg the heavens for relief from the weights that seem to be shackled to her heart’s every desire. I looked up too, though not in hopes of relief, but rather of thankfulness for the moment I was able to experience. As the chaos of a week-long music festival roared outside there was a calm in the room that is hard to describe. The people in that room, myself included, were not concerned with anything on the planet other than the person standing on stage, and for the entirety of her set Julien Baker maintained that unshakable hold on our collective attention spans until time demanded she release us back into the madness of the outside world. We didn’t want to go, and in a way I think she didn’t want to either. We had all just been a part of something special, and the memory of that time will continue to inspire me every day of my life moving forward.


James Shotwell is the Digital Marketing Manager for Haulix, as well as the host of the Inside Music Podcast. He is also the Film Editor for Substream Magazine and co-founder of Antique Records. Whenever free, James tends to spend his time watching Law & Order reruns while playing with his two fat cats, Chub E Chubs and Paws Von Trier, in his tiny Minneapolis apartment. If you like the article you just read you should probably follow James on Twitter.

Categories
News

Tips And Tricks For Covering Vans Warped Tour

Hello and welcome to a very special mid-week edition of our popular Journalism Tips series. We normally hold these columns until Saturday, but due to the time sensitive nature of the content contained within this post we decided to run it a few days early. Don’t worry, there will be something new on Saturday too.

This blog exists to promote the future of the music industry, and to do that we need input from people like you and your music-loving friends. If you have any questions about the content in this article, or if you have an artist you would like to see featured on this blog, please contact james@haulix.com and share your thoughts. We can also be found on Twitter and Facebook.

There was a time not too long ago when I would have thought we talked about Vans Warped Tour too much. While it’s true that many labels who use Haulix to service their artist’s latest releases have participated in Warped Tour at least once or twice in the past, it’s not true for every single one of our clients and we often worry about giving any one area of music too much attention via this blog. In 2014, however, Warped Tour is a far different beast than it has been during any other year that I can remember. The punk and hard rock elements are still firmly in tact, but the world’s largest traveling music festival has also expanded its musical offerings to include people from the world of EDM, rap, pop, and beyond. Some complain, but I think it’s ultimately for the best, and if you’re smart about how you approach your coverage of Warped Tour you may find it has the potential to be one of, if not the most rewarding coverage experience(s) you have all year.

I know that every writer has their own method and routine when it comes to interviews and live coverage, but that does not mean you’re incapable of improvement. To help get this point across, I asked Absolutepunk staffer and all-round badass music blogger Jake Denning to provide a few coverage tips and tricks for those who have yet to attend the 2014 installment of Warped Tour. He agreed, and after a few back and forth conversations we settled on a nice list that I think drives home the idea that you can never truly perfect your interview style. In truth, you can only plan, practice, and hope for the best. Put yourself in the best possible position to succeed and do whatever it takes to make your goals a reality.

Without further ado, here’s Jake…

I recognize the advice I’m about to share is not gospel, but I feel like it will help some looking for some tips when it comes to doing press the Warped Tour (or any festival in general).

BEFORE YOUR APPROVED DATE:

1. Make sure you’ve turned in the interview request form that was sent to you when approved for press. Some interviews (such as The Summer Set and The Ghost Inside) require advance approval, and if you don’t turn in the form well in advance of your show date, there is absolutely no chance you will speak to that band.

2. Make sure you have a plan for food/water. My personal preference is to pack the following: (1) Quest Protein Bar, (1) 3.25oz bag of Jerky, and (1) Small bag of Trail Mix, along with (1) Empty gatorade sports bottle (you can generally find these at any sporting goods store for about $2-5, VERY useful).

ON THE DAY OF THE SHOW:

1. Have your batteries charged, your memory clean, your bag/gear organized

2. Get to venue and find yellow Vans tent well in advance of check-in time (generally 10:30am local time). This allows you to be ready to go when it comes time to enter the venue, and find the press area as quickly as possible

3. Once you’ve found the press area and you’ve introduced yourself and signed in, find the performance schedule, typically located next to the interview sign-up sheets. From there, momentarily forget about doing interviews for the day, and build a schedule based on what bands you’d like to watch. Ideally, you shouldn’t have more than 20 minutes between sets, as to maximize the day. Once you have that schedule, THEN start to remove performances that conflict with press times for a particular artist (For instance, if Every Time I Die is doing press from 1pm – 1:40pm and you’d like to see Motionless In White at 1:20…well, looks like you’re not watching Motionless In White)

4. HAVE AN OUTLINE – I recognize this is not for everyone, but for someone who tries to hit on the album/release a particular artist is touring on, this is essential for me. I need specific notes detailing my critical thoughts on said release, as well as questions pertaining to lyrical content, etc. You will never get a chance to interview this artist again on this specific day, so be as detailed as you can be in this setting.

5. Be mindful of when a particular artist is scheduled to interview and be mindful of when they arrive. Be near the press table when they arrive, so that you have a better chance of getting to interview them. To be honest, not every publication that signs up on the list (even if they’re first to sign up) will get to interview. For example, I had an artist come in that 7 different people (including myself) had signed up for – the Tour Manager routed them to AltPress, myself, and then one other publication, and then promptly left.

6. After an interview is done, IMMEDIATELY find a way to upload to Dropbox (or favorite cloud storage provider) – Things happen.

7. Chances are that you’re probably going to end up charging your phone/laptop/etc at some point in the day – take that opportunity to connect with other people/artists in the room. Plague Vendor (Epitaph) ended up on my radar because I ended up getting to know them for 20 minutes or so, not knowing who they were before hand.

8. Last, but certainly not least, FOLLOW THE RULES given to you when approved – for example, if you’re in a venue that does not allow video, then DON’T shoot video and claim you didn’t know about the rule afterwards.

Jake Denning is an entertainment writer and critic with years of experience working online. He has interviewed dozens of bands and written about more albums than you have probably heard in your entire lifetime. He’s a smart go-getter with a blindingly bright future ahead of him and we’re grateful that he was willing to help us with this post. If you would like to learn more about his efforts in music and beyond, click here to follow Jake on Twitter.

Exit mobile version